A Global Phenomenon Part II: Aggravated in Australia

Last year, we published a blog post highlighting creators, authors, rightsholders, and others in several countries who were expressing their outrage against AI companies getting a free pass to steal copyrighted works. Almost two years later, the chorus of anger and concern and the demands that countries respect copyright continue. In fact, that chorus of disenchantment is growing with the largest outcry happening in the land down under. Australia has taken center stage because its government is considering adopting statutory licensing schemes that would permit AI companies around the globe to take the copyrighted works for AI training on government-set terms.

How Did Australia Get Here?

Australia has historically been a strong supporter of the creative and media sectors and the copyright laws that support them. Like many countries in the world, the Australian Government has been examining its laws and policies to find ways to leverage the AI boom—an examination which has included the question of whether its copyright laws should be amended to fuel AI development. Creators and rightsholders were initially encouraged by positive messages from the Australian Government about the importance of copyright.

In 2025, the Productivity Commission (PC) concluded in a report that its proposed AI copyright exception would be premature, recommending instead that the Australian Government should take a wait and see approach to allow AI licensing markets “to develop without interference.” In July 2026, Australia’s Prime Minister Anthony Albanese affirmed the importance of creators and artists and upholding their copyrights in Australia when he gave promising remarks about the country’s AI interests, stating: “No company should use Australian books, music, art or news to build or train AI without the artist’s control. That includes the artist’s control of the price and value of their work. Anything less, is theft.” This statement and others certainly made it seem that Australia was committed to strong copyright laws that support creators and rightsholders.

But in a shocking and disturbing reversal, a few months later, the Australian Government decided to take a different approach, one that seems to heavily favor the AI companies. The Government has launched closed-door consultations on its proposals of problematic statutory licensing regimes that would permit the use of all copyrighted works for AI training on government set terms. The proposals included options of statutory licensing schemes with an opt-out regime and a licensing quota scheme where AI companies who fulfill the quota have a safe harbor against infringement liability arising from using any other work on the internet for AI training. Unsurprisingly, this policy flip flop has resulted in an uproar from the creative community and many others, both in Australia and throughout the rest of the globe.

The Australian Government’s AI copyright licensing proposals are problematic chiefly because they undermine copyright by crippling the ability of creators and copyright owners to license and otherwise exercise their copyrights. But the proposals are also problematic for a litany of other reasons including that they:

  • impose a one-size-fits-all solution on all creative works and sectors that undermines creative and business models as it shows no regard for differences in the type of works, the business and financial models, the way works are used in the generative AI context, and several other important differences;
  • fail to address the complex reality of the myriad circumstances under which copyright is implicated by generative AI including for training and post-training uses;
  • devalue creative works. Despite what a buyer may pay for in a free market for the true value of a work, statutory licenses defy market realities by deeming that all creative works are worth exactly the same, in spite of differences in value, type of work, labor, artistry, craftmanship, and other factors;
  • implicate foreign copyrights in a manner that raises trade and international copyright treaty compliance issues under Australia’s free trade agreements and the Berne Convention; and

If the Australian Government were to adopt these statutory licensing proposals, it would be an outlier. No other country in the world has a statutory license for AI training that is even remotely similar to what Australia is considering adopting.  In fact, multiple other governments around the world have rejected proposals to weaken their copyright laws including the United Kingdom, Hong Kong, Colombia, Chile, and India. India in particular had considered a statutory licensing scheme for AI use of copyrighted works, which quickly garnered incredible backlash from all stakeholders, including those from the technology sector. For a country with a long history of being copyright friendly, that would a terrible turn of events for Australia and would likely result in a mass exodus of creativity from the country.

Significantly, it is also worth pointing out that, of the minority of global regimes that have AI copyright exceptions, those governments are struggling mightily with the legal and practical implementation and implications of their AI copyright exceptions. Unsurprisingly, those exceptions have failed to deliver on promises of clarity, control, or innovation. In the European Union, Singapore, and Japan uncertainties remain as to what stages of AI development and deployment are covered by their AI copyright exceptions and how “safeguards” like opt-out systems and lawful access requirements are to be implemented and shouldered by individual artists, creators, and other rightsholders who lack resources, technical systems, expertise, and control in the digital environment, particularly over downstream uses including piracy. When taking into account to date the experiences of the EU, Singapore and Japan, it’s inexplicable why Australia, or any other country for that matter, would what to invite that type of chaos and uncertainty into its law.

Creators and Rightsholders Have Not Held Back Against the Proposals

The Australian creative community have been vociferous with their frustration and aggravation at the news of the proposed licensing schemes. The Australian creative and media sectors gathered to launch its protest with the “Not AI’s to Take” campaign, calling creators and rightsholders to petition the Australian government and members of Parliament to protect Australian creativity and uphold the copyright laws that support it. At the Australian music industry’s biggest awards show, the ARIA Awards, numerous Australian artists and musicians took their red carpet interviews to champion the importance of upholding the copyright laws that fuel their livelihoods so that they can continue creating sounds and stories and be remunerated for them in a way that they deserve. Even famed UK musician, Elton John, who famously recorded his platinum album, Live in Australia with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra, made a surprise appearance at the event, delivering a message to the Australian Government and stating: “You have a duty to protect Australian artists and their work. Don’t let AI use any Australian artist’s work without full permission. Please, protect the next generation of Australian artists.”

It goes to show that Australian creators and rightsholders are not alone in this fight against attempts to undermine copyright and legalize AI theft. The global creative community stands with the Australian creative community. Here are just a few examples:

  • A group of 63 international media organizations sent a letter to the Australian Government decrying the proposals.
  • The Authors Guild [CG1] organized a petition calling on the creative community to sign the statement: “The Australian government must not legalize the theft of the work of the world’s creators on their soil. Our work must only be used to train AI models in Australia with our explicit permission.”
  • In a letter to Prime Minister Albanese, the Digital Creators Coalition (DCC), a group of U.S. creator and rightsholders organizations pushed back against the proposals, noting numerous fallacies and international treaty and trade implications of the proposals.
  • The Copyright Alliance recently sent a letter to the Australian Government, pointing out the fallacies with the proposals, clarifying that developments in U.S. law do not warrant the statutory licensing proposals, and calling on the Australian Government to uphold and enforce its copyright laws rather than undermining them.
  • Baroness Beeban Kidron of the UK Parliament, an award-winning filmmaker who was instrumental in fighting back sweeping AI copyright exceptions in the UK, cautioned Prime Minister Albanese to “not squander his reputation by selling Australian creatives down the river,” while recounting the incredible backlash that the UK government had faced in its own ill-advised AI copyright proposals.

Conclusion

Copyright has never been as important as it is now. Creators and rightsholders live in the age of generative AI technologies where their creative works have been taken and used without permission to develop and use in AI models that are capable of generating output that mimic and affect the markets of underlying works. Australia is just the latest country to take a misstep that has aggravated the creative community and united them in their response to problematic proposals. Like those other countries, Australia should reject these proposals.

The Australian Government, and other governments, should understand the issues raised in the creative community’s responses and understand how important copyright is to a county’s economy, culture and its voice, and of course to the success of generative AI. It is imperative that the Australian Government continue upholding the copyright laws that supports its creative sectors and Australian culture and the creators, authors, and rightsholders behind it all.


To stay up to date with the latest news in artificial intelligence (AI) and copyright, sign up for our AI Copyright Alert. You can also visit our AI and Copyright hub for additional resources on federal court cases, current licensing, and more. Additionally, if you aren’t already a member of the Copyright Alliance, you can join today by completing our Creator Membership form! Members gain access to monthly newsletters, educational webinars, and so much more — all for free!

get blog updates